Who We Are.
Since 2005, Postema Insurance & Investments, LLC has provided seniors with innovative solutions for their Retirement Planning needs.
Contact Us
2005
Founded
A reputation built on quality and care.
Since 2005, Postema Insurance & Investments, LLC has provided seniors with innovative solutions for their Retirement Planning needs. We have since expanded to include Health, Life, Home, and Auto insurance. Our prompt, courteous, and personal service has allowed us to enjoy a reputation as a client-oriented agency dedicated to providing quality solutions for our clients.
Coverage Areas
The Postema Difference
"The convenience of a small shop, the expertise of a huge corporation."
Simplicity. Peace of Mind. Legacy.
We are the perfect combination of the convenience and integrity of a small mom and pop shop with all the experience and expertise of a huge corporation. Our unique position allows you to touch base with all your services in a single phone call because we believe in simplicity and peace of mind. We strive to build confidence, trust, and long-lasting relationships with each of our clients.
Postema Insurance & Investments, LLC exists to protect everything you've worked for by providing customized financial services to each of our clients.
Our Team.
17 dedicated specialists committed to building confidence, trust, and long-lasting relationships with each of our clients.
Dennis M. Postema
Dennis established PI&I in 2005 with a vision to provide superior, personalized financial solutions.
Dennis M. Postema
Founder & CEO
Dennis established PI&I in 2005 with a vision to provide superior, personalized financial solutions.
Krista Postema Burroughs
COO
Krista has been with the agency for over 10 years and has played a big part in its growth and success, leading day-to-day operations while overseeing the Medicare Division.
Thomas E. Postema
Life, Health, Financial Representative
Thomas is a dedicated financial representative specializing in life and health solutions, committed to securing the futures of families across the region.
Michael Sebring
Life, Health, Financial Representative
Mike works with clients to help them protect what matters most and plan for the future, while also supporting and developing agents as a Field Sales Trainer.
John Postema
Life, Health, Financial Representative
John is a Medicare Consultant dedicated to helping clients make confident decisions about their coverage and future.
Geoffrey Bowman
District Manager, Cleveland Branch
Geoff is the District Manager of the Cleveland Branch with a strong background in helping clients with their life insurance needs.
Carrie Carr
COO Postema Entities
Carrie is a valued part of the office, known for being dependable, hardworking, and someone others can count on.
Leslie Roberts
Director of Operations/Office Manager
Leslie supports both PII and PMG through her work with agent licensing and policies, keeping processes moving smoothly.
Kathy Shrader
Chief Financial Officer, Postema Accounting Solutions
With a diverse background spanning artistic businesses, accounting, and finance, Kathy brings deep expertise to Postema Accounting Solutions as Tax and Accounting Specialist.
Spencer Kramer
IT Manager
Spencer oversees the technology needs of the office, managing systems and solving technical issues to keep everything running smoothly.
Gloria Spencer
Office Manager
Gloria ensures the daily operations of the office run seamlessly, providing essential support to both the team and our clients.
Peggy Sisco
Director of Operations (P and C Division)
Peggy leads the operational strategy for our Property and Casualty division, ensuring efficient processing and exceptional service standards.
Tyler Johnson
Home, Auto, and Business Representative
Tyler specializes in protecting the foundations of your daily life: your home, your vehicles, and your livelihood.
Tim Schortgen
Home, Auto, and Business Representative
Tim provides expert guidance on home and business protection, ensuring your most valuable assets are shielded with care.
Noah Svanberg
Health Representative
Noah navigates the complexities of health coverage to ensure you and your family have access to the care you need.
Grant Quaderer
Life, Health, Financial Representative
Grant provides holistic financial and insurance solutions designed to secure your family's long-term legacy.
Find Us.
Postema Insurance and Investments, LLC has 2 locations, a corporate office in Defiance, OH and a satellite office in Hamilton, IN.
Defiance, OH
Corporate Office
2014 Baltimore St., Defiance, OH 43512
419-782-2500
Hamilton, IN
Satellite Office
350 Main St, Suite 203
260-488-2400
Your future
starts with a
single call.
Our unique position allows you to touch base with all your services in a single phone call because we believe in simplicity and peace of mind.